50 Comments
Aug 18, 2023·edited Aug 18, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

Derek, I am so sorry this happened to you, but I am glad that your church wounds are not causing you to give up on God. He will lead you. I wish you could meet my pastor; you would find him to be a kindred spirit in many ways. I'm sharing a link to his book about youth ministry. I'm sure there are more likeminded believers out there than you realize who will value what you have to offer, whether or not you ever pursue professional ministry again. I will pray that God leads you to the right church in his time.:) While it's true that most denominations have issues, there ARE faithful Christians out there. Usually they're not the ones getting the accolades.

I also wanted to say that, for what it's worth, I wholeheartedly agree with your decisions: Kids DO need time with parents, much more than they need fun events. This is one of the crises of our modern life, I think. Discipleship is so much more important than numbers: Jesus poured into twelve people for three years, and they went on to change the world.

https://www.amazon.com/Giving-Up-Gimmicks-Reclaiming-Entertainment/dp/1596383941

Expand full comment
author

Thank you for reading!! And thank you for the encouragement. I know that among the broken churches, there are good ones. I'm not looking for anything perfect because that simply does not exist. And THANK YOU for understanding my view on family time. The church I was writing about made me feel crazy for wanting to prioritize family. Thank you also for the book recommendation! I will adds that to my long list of books I need to read.

Expand full comment
Aug 19, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

I just realized that I called you Derek...is that your brother? Sorry for the mistake!

Expand full comment
author

Derek is my brother! My twin brother actually. It’s an honest mistake so don’t feel bad at all.

Expand full comment
Aug 19, 2023·edited Aug 19, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

I've had some really painful church experiences, too; you're not alone! Also wanted to share a potentially unpopular opinion: In my experience, it is a church's culture that matters more than its theology (aside from serious heresy). I can (and do) disagree intellectually with some of the distinctive theological tenets my church teaches (though I am in agreement on the basics, which is why I am a member), but I cannot escape becoming like--in some degree--the people I surround myself with. Even if I disagree with the theology that gives rise to the cultural behavior! So I think it's important to choose very wisely: do I want to BE like these people?

Expand full comment
Aug 18, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

Ditto on the family time thing. I really think a primary function of parish life should be to support the family, not replace or compete with it.

Expand full comment
Aug 18, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

Amen, amen, amen.

Expand full comment

Daniel, that was a gripping and painful tale. It is experiences like this that would make people question going to church ( if I were a seeker hearing about the hard-hearted nature of this congregation I would definitely not step a foot into church). I think taking time to reflect and pray and not feeling hurried to join a congregation is a good call. Blessings to you and your family.

Expand full comment
author

Thank you for reading and for your prayers. God willing, we will find a great church In the not-too-distant future.

Expand full comment
Aug 18, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

I offered Mass for you and your family this morning, Daniel. This is such a hard place to be, but I hope and pray and trust that the Lord will lead you home soon. Your devotion to maintaining your prayer + scripture study is so admirable (if you ever want to lead a Substack bible study I'm THERE) as is your determination to find a spiritual home for your children.

I know a couple other Catholics have chimed in here (and I think Hambone and Scoot to over on notes in Isa's thread a few weeks ago) but if there are any questions we can answer about the Catholic/Orthodox side of things, I know we're all happy to play a role in your discernment. But of course, we're all praying for you already!

Expand full comment
Aug 19, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

I love the idea of an ecumenical Substack Bible study, if anyone would ever be open to that. :)

Expand full comment
author

I really really like that idea.

Expand full comment

I’m also interested!

Expand full comment
Aug 18, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

Alone in the world is an extremely dangerous place to be. The church can also be a dangerous place to be and yet that is where God calls us to serve and be served. My folks were beat up by various churches and for years operated a hospital for other Christians who had been beat up and needed to know that God was present in the storm.

I am thankful for that experience. It has guided me to seek healthy churches and deal with unhealthy situations. I am also very grateful to have been a member of the same body of believers for the past 25 years.

Do not join a perfect church, you will spoil it. Do seek an elder led body intent on following God and His Word. The Firm Foundation is far more than a metaphor.

Blessings.

Expand full comment
author

Thank you for reading and for your comments! As an imperfect man, I don't think I would recognize a perfect church even if one existed. I do want to find one with wise elders. We will find one though. Like I said, I was knocked down, not out.

Expand full comment

God is good.

The smart alek quote was courtesy of Bishop Ryle. Apparently finding a church is an old problem.

Expand full comment
Aug 18, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

Based on your preference for Orthodoxy over Catholicism, I'm gonna go out on a limb and say that the teachings you don't agree with as far as Catholicism have to do with the papacy, lol.

I'm sorry you went through this. The experience of corrupt pastors and church politics is pretty universal, unfortunately. I'm a Catholic who worked in ministry for a bit, and I've got a few stories of my own. People everywhere, including in the Church, can be really awful and it's especially awful when it's someone who's supposed to be bringing others to Christ.

Because you're considering Orthodoxy, I do think it's worth noting that the function of "church" is very different between the more evangelical branches of Christianity and the Catholic and Orthodox. Church attendance for both those groups (Catholic and Orthodox) is required because it's participating in a Sacrament, rather than encouraged to foster support and community in people's walk with Christ. That second part SHOULD be there in a decent parish, but the first part is ALWAYS there. Proper worship is participating in that liturgical act, and that's why everyone is showing up. That can lead to some pretty big cultural differences between Catholics (not sure about Orthodox as I've had only limited exposure to their congregations, but as that understanding is the same I imagine some of the issues might be the same) and evangelical Protestant congregations.

I mention this because you might want to consider researching what proper "worship" ought to be. Is it meant to be community participation in a liturgy, or is it something that can be carried out by an individual? That research might give you some direction as to where God is calling you in all this.

I think I know the answer, but this is obviously something you're going to have to figure out for yourself to be convicted one way or the other.

Prayers for your journey, brother. ❤️

Expand full comment
author

Thank you so much for your insights. I really appreciate your point about the differences in the function of the church between the denominations. I have come to really appreciate the reverence that the Catholics and Orthodox have for Sacrament and the liturgy. I have indeed looked into the traditional understanding of what “Worship” is and I have even wondered if Protestants are approaching worship correctly. I know that's a bold thing to say but that's where I am. I think community is necessary. Its important to have certain practices and disciplines down on an individual level, but being part of the bride of Christ requires community.

Thank you for reading, for your thoughts and for your prayers. God bless!

Expand full comment
Aug 27, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

I am very sorry to hear about your experience. This should not have happened in any church!

There is an answer I can see- if my suggestion is of any help to you- try visiting the Orthodox Church you mentioned. As a convert to Orthodoxy I have never met anything but warm welcome and a deepening of my relationship with God in the Orthodox Church.

Whilst other churches weaken and fall victim to the trends of today, Orthodoxy remains strong in spirit and in action. That is not to say that there are no flaws- where there are humans there are flaws. But I see it as the Christian way forward.

I think your decision to wait is very sensible and by no means hurry. But I hope that if anything can help you in your dilemma, Orthodoxy can.

Well done on remaining strong in faith even in the face or adversity.

Expand full comment
Aug 18, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

It was interesting reading your post as someone who doesn't believe in Youth Pastors :)

Expand full comment
author

Would you mind elaborating as to why you don’t believe in youth pastors? It’s really interesting you said that because, shortly before I was fired, I saw a video where Pastor Voddie Baucham talk about how youth groups were unnecessary and unbiblical and it was very persuasive. I honestly couldn’t find anything wrong with what he was saying. Have you seen that video?

Expand full comment
Aug 18, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

I wouldn't mind in the slightest. Hopefully that will become obvious about me, I never mind explaining :) or arguing :)

Yes, Voddie's arguments are ones I would use. I am opposed to anything in church that breaks up the family, except for certain male/female distinctions. I grew up with fourth-grade boys Sunday school being a thing... and while I enjoyed it, it isn't at all Biblical, and it did bad things to the families.

As well, I would have a problem with using the word 'pastor' for the position. If you look at the qualifications for elders in the Scripture (if you look at the name!) I think that you will find that most of the youth pastors don't come close to fulfilling the qualifications. How many of them have well-regulated households with believing children who have stood the test of time.

Expand full comment
author

I do know of some who have very solid households but on the whole I agree with you. What denomination are you a member of?

Expand full comment
Aug 18, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

Our church is not officially part of a denomination, but we are reformed Baptists, LBC 1689.

Expand full comment
author

Well Von, I’m getting offline for a while. But seriously, thank you so much for the conversation. It started off a little rough but I thank you for challenging what I wrote. It will help me get better. I look forward to and welcome future Von critiques on my writings. Have a wonderful evening and weekend. God Bless!

Expand full comment
Aug 18, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

Anytime, dude, anytime. I signed up to your stack, so I'll see what you write. Hopefully you will comment on my stuff as well :)

Expand full comment

I am so sorry you had to experience that; I had some rough experiences with the church I grew up in (and am not in now, long story), but I understand; kids and family take priority. I'll definitely pray for you to find a good church; I'm Catholic myself, but to borrow a metaphor I read once, the Lord has a big fleet with a lot of ships, and we're all headed towards the same port. Whatever ship you land in, he'll meet you there.

Expand full comment
author

Thank you for reading and for your thoughts! I believe God can and does work wondered despite our silly divisions and I believe he will lead us to where we need to be.

Expand full comment
Aug 18, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

Daniel - Thank you so much for your willingness to share this.

It is sad that those who are called to represent and serve Christ through serving others can be so selfish and callous and have no compunction about lying with it suits their purposes.

I was fortunate that when I was saved, I plugged into an independent local Bible Church (similar in doctrine to Baptist), where the pastor eventually became my father-in-law. He was a wonderful Bible teacher, going verse by verse through books of the Bible. When I first attended there, he had just started through the book of Romans in a week night Bible Study and taught through that book for the next 5 years. I could not have asked for a better way to be grounded in the faith.

That being said, we have moved around to various states for work and graduate school/seminary, so had to look for churches where we could continue to be fed and could be involved. I have found that staying away from denominations all together (I grew up in the Episcopalian Church) is best. so we always looked for independent baptist or bible churches.

Sadly even many of those churches were not suitable because there was either a strong authoritarian pastor (my way or the highway type), or they almost literally put being baptist before being a Christian. I had a pastor once who called this the big-B Baptist "Bodies, Bucks, and Bricks" syndrome.

It's hard, Brother, I know. I have felt tempted to quit going to church as well. So far, by God's grace we have been able to find suitable ministries that we can become part of, yet still have reservations about some of the practices.

We will not go to any church where the pastor and other elders/deacons do not view themselves and actually act as servants of Christ.

But, I think as long as sinful people are in places of ministry, it will be like that no matter what.

So, my 2 cents is:

* Look for an independent church not affiliated with a denomination,

* Look for preaching that feeds the congregation, not just repetitive salvation messages

* Beware of huge congregations and churches with catchy marketing type names and are only interested in numbers.

The Lord will lead you to the right place, Brother.

Expand full comment
author

Thank you, Cork! I will definitely consider your advice as we look for a church. But we will look and we will find one to attend. It’ too important. I refuse to be done with church even though I got hurt. That’s just not an option.

Expand full comment
Aug 18, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

I know y'all will find just the right place to plug in.

It's interesting that there are so many folks (not including you in this category, BTW) who do not attend church because they've been hurt by someone. And others who say they don't go because "the church is full of hypocrites". Sometimes, I want to reply, "well you should feel right at home, then."

In reality, these folks don't really want to go to church and use these as convenient excuses. We should have a heart for the fellowship of the saints, especially in light of the reasons given in Hebrews 10:22-25 of why we should be in a local church.

Keep on looking and praying.

Expand full comment
Dec 20, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

I've found that times of loss and seeking can be times where we grow most in discernment and wisdom. I see that in your writing. I'll add you & your family to my prayers, that you find a church home.

The corporate mentality has taken over many non-profits, which creates an inescapable conflict between leadership teams & employees who are there out of a sense of vocation. I have experienced this in healthcare, and see it at work in education as well. Good for you for not trying to scramble to meet their unrealistic demand for numbers.

Expand full comment
author

Thank you, Erin for your prayers, and for talking the time to read this post. I have become sure that this difficult season is all apart of God’s plan. The earnest seeking will be worth it in the end.

Expand full comment
Nov 18, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

Daniel, thank you for sharing this personal story! I will pray that you find a church home as soon as possible. I am glad you are interested in the Orthodox Church. I wanted to share some resources for your wife (and kids as they get older). I have been at home in the Orthodox Church my whole life and there is no other place where you will be as directly nourished by Christ. Some of my favorite online Orthodox resources for women are:

- Ascetic Life of Motherhood blog https://www.asceticlifeofmotherhood.com/homescreen

- Seven Holy Women book https://store.ancientfaith.com/seven-holy-women-conversations-with-saints-and-friends/

- Parenting toward the Kingdom https://store.ancientfaith.com/parenting-toward-the-kingdom/

I’m sure you’re already familiar with the book Orthodoxy and Heterodoxy as well - it’s a must-read!

It sounds like your kids are still pretty little but here are two YouTube channels with Orthodox content for kids…

- Ancient Faith Kids https://www.youtube.com/@ancientfaith4kids

- Patristic Nectar Kids https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCO7NEdeuYd4AU-CiK46dscA

Blessings and prayers and may God lead you where you’re meant to be.

Expand full comment
author

Thank you so much for taking the time to read, comment and for sharing all of those resources! Especially for those for my wife and children. I truly appreciate that. And yes, please to pray for me!

Expand full comment

I’m so sorry you’ve been through all this, Daniel - as a pastor’s daughter I have some secondhand experience with churches’ expectations being entirely unclear, and the pain that can cause. Did I read correctly that you’re still living in Columbus, GA? I took a look at my church body’s church locator and found what looks like a very solid church (in my estimation) in Columbus. I’m linking to the explanation of the denomination on that specific congregation’s website, and of course you can click around from there - but I thought it you might like to start there since you mentioned you’ve been looking into the teachings of various denominations. If I can answer any questions about the denomination for you, just let me know!

https://redeemercolumbusga.org/what-is-an-lcms-lutheran/

Expand full comment

Well, I think my comment here might be a little out of the norm, but I don't really see, in light of the article above, why you aren't in church. Sort of the only thing you didn't seem to explain was why you are a church-less Christian.

Expand full comment
author

I’m church-less because my latest experience in a church, where I served at Youth Pastor ended with the pastor and the board firing me for unidentified and unrealistic expectations. Which left me unemployed and my life has been busy and complicated ever since. But I long to be in a church and am now looking for one to join. Sorry none of that was clear enough for you.

Expand full comment
Aug 18, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

I wasn't trying to be offensive, I'm saying that the article seemed to leave out the spiritual struggle and the family decisions that led to 'we're not going to church today'. For many families that is a week by week struggle... will we go this week. Pastors that have been kicked out by their congregations, people kicked out for holding Biblical beliefs, people with time issues... they all struggle with going every week.

Expand full comment
author

Also, I did assume you were trying be offensive. That’s my bad. I guess years spent on the internet have made me a little callous. I am thankful you commented became it has now started an interesting conversation. And as I said before I can work on being more clear as I wrote.

Expand full comment

Oh, its easy to take my comments as offensive. I'm rather... blunt? Obnoxious?

Expand full comment
author

Maybe if you started with “just trying to help” or “don’t take this the wrong way” or something like that it would help strangers like me know your intentions.

Expand full comment
Aug 18, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

Well, someone says 'don't take this the wrong way' to me, and my hackles go up :)

But, yeah, I could try something like that. I guess I'm so old that I don't get how quick today's people are to take offence.

Expand full comment
author

I guess for me it began with the firing and then the various jobs I got and now having two kids under two, one under 2 months, has created time issues. Plus my family and I live in a very rural area. I appreciate you pointing out I could have made all of that more clear. I’m still very unpolished as a writer and will remember to work on the clarity of the subject as I keep working to improve.

Expand full comment
Aug 18, 2023Liked by Daniel Joseph Petty

The rural area issue can be a big one, depending on where you are. We live in Rural Texas, where there are several churches in every small town. If you have particular doctrinal constraints it can still be difficult to find a church to go to.

But I would encourage you to... just go. Just tell the wife that you're going, figure out the times from the internet, work on getting ready early on Sunday... and go. Sure, it won't be the best church, but it will be better than staying home. Forsake not the fellowship and all that. You probably have a lot of friends in your rural community, ask them where they go. But go. Seriously. Go.

Expand full comment
author

I appreciate the encouragement! I have every intention on going soon.

Expand full comment

Well, today's Friday so... :)

Expand full comment